Ordering Rectangles:
1. Take the seven rectangles and lay them out in front of you. Look at their perimeters. Do not do any measuring; just look. What are your first hunches? Which rectangle do you think has the smallest perimeter? The largest perimeter? Move the rectangles around until you have ordered them from the one with the smallest perimeter to the one with the largest perimeter. Record your order. After laying out the rectangles, I thought D had the smallest perimeter and G had the largest. I ordered them from greatest to smallest as follows: G-A-E-C-F-B-D
2. Now look at the rectangles and consider their areas. What are your first hunches? Which rectangle has the smallest area? The largest area? Again, without doing any measuring, order the rectangles from the one with the smallest area to the one with the largest area. Record your order. I thought C had the smallest area while G had the largest area. I ordered them as follows: G-A-E-F-B-D-C
3. Now, by comparing directly or using any available materials (color tiles are always useful), order the rectangles by perimeter. How did your estimated order compare with the actual order? What strategy did you use to compare perimeters? I used color tiles to measure the perimeter of the rectangles. I ordered them as follows: F-G-A-B-D-E-C. My estimated order was pretty off the measured order. I didn't have any in the same order after measuring them with color tiles.
4. By comparing directly or using any available materials (again…color tiles), order the rectangles by area. How did your estimated order compare with the actual order? What strategy did you use to compare areas? I used color tiles to measure the area of the rectangles. I found their order to be: G-A-F-B-E-D-C. I was closer with my guessing for area than for perimeter. I did guess the rectangles with the greatest and least area.
I also correctly guessed a few in the middle.
5. What ideas about perimeter, about area, or about measuring did these activities help you to see? What questions arose as you did this work? What have you figured out? What are you still wondering about? Share your responses to all the questions in 1-5 on your blog. Spend some time discussing your answers with your blog partner. This activity helped me see that the largest area shape may not have the largest perimeter. It can be tricky when guessing the perimeter or area of a shape because it's hard to see that by just looking at them. There was some small space left when measuring some of the rectangles with the color tiles and I wondered how I should incorporate those spaces. I tried to compare the left over spaces when shapes had the same number of squares for perimeter or area. I lined the tiles up on the edge of the rectangle and then used another tile to estimate the left over space. However, my cutting of the shape may have caused some error in this way of measuring. I'm still not sure the best way to handle the extra spaces.
Annenberg:
I thought this was an interesting session. I have never measured anything by wrapping it in foil. I thought that would be an interesting way to show students about measuring irregular shapes. I was surprised by the following questions answer:
How does a three-arm balance scale work? Can you determine the weight of your rock with this balance?
If you have access to a three-arm balance, use it to determine the weight of your rock
I thought a three-arm balance could give you the weight of the rock not an approximation. What type of scale can give a definite weight? This session really made me think about the approximation of measuring. I think I thought it was much more definite in certain cases.
Case Studies:
The case studies showed a progression in understanding of measurement through the grade levels. The kindergarten students were showing they understand where to start and stop when measuring an object. They were just learning that you need a unit of some sort to measure with. The first grade students were working through the understanding that if the unit you measure with is larger the less times you have to use it to measure with. The students first thought the larger number was related to the larger item used to measure with. The third grade students were working on the same understanding as the first grade students. They were also learning about precision and accuracy. They were starting to understand that the precision with which they measured had a direct affect on the accuracy of their results. They were discovery what errors could occur while measuring to cause errors in the results. The second grade students were also learning about precision and accuracy. They were learning that measurement is an approximation. The fourth grade students were working with choosing the right measuring tool for the measuring task they were completing and how to properly use that tool. Students were discussing where you start measuring at the '0' space on a ruler. The seventh graders were working with units, regular and irregular. They were having some trouble understanding the irregular units used would result in different results where the regular units should have resulted in the same results.
TCM Article: Length
What ideas will you take from this article into your classroom? Was there anything surprising about what you read that made you change your thinking about children’s understanding of unit? What possible misconceptions may children have about measurement? I was surprised that the students were quickly able to move from direct measurements to the more deductive reasoning. I was surprised how much the first graders understood about measurement. Macy was able to make a unit to compare two areas. She also understands the bigger the unit the more space it takes up and so you use it less times to measure something. I was also surprised by the ease in which the students used letters to express relationships between quantities. I would definitely use this approach in my classroom. I like that students moved from physically measuring to more conceptual ideas. These students have a much better understanding of measurement than students who may be taught a formula and given worksheets to practice measuring with.












