My first two impressions are the common core standards seem pretty detailed and well explained. The progression seems good through the grades. However, I don't see why you you should wait, for example, until 2nd grade to teach graphing. You can start that in kindergarten. As the standards progress through the grades, they get more detailed and require more finesse from the student to accomplish the goals. They require more understanding of the concepts to complete the goals as well. The common core standards align in some places with the NCTM standards, but the NCTM standards have more requirements in them. For instance, the common core and NCTM state students should be able to count and classify objects into categories. The NCTM specifies attribute categories where the common core just says categories. They both state students should be able to represent data but only the NCTM says in a concrete way. Both standard types state students should be able to interpret data parts compared to the whole to describe what the data shows. Only NCTM discusses students expressing experiences as likely or unlikely. Only NCTM mentions data collection by the students. Both common core and NCTM state students in 3-5 grade should use line graphs, line plots, bar graphs. Only the NCTM states students should be able to explain the difference in categorical and numerical data. Both standards state students should be able to talk about the shape of data as it's center and spread.
Curriculum Resources
I chose the grade four: how many people are in your family?
1. When using this activity, what mathematical ideas would you want your students to work through? I would first want my students to understand the importance of how they formulate their question to ask when collecting data. I would want my student's to find a way to collect the data and keep track of it. Then, I would want student's to be able to show their data in a concrete way. Students could use blocks or other manipulative's to show their data. I would like students to understand how to interpret or analyze their data by looking at the mean and spread. I would finally like students to be able to express their data using a graph.
2. How would you work to bring that mathematics out? I would break this lesson over several days so we could focus on one piece at a time. I would first work to help student's define their question for collecting data and discuss as a class the importance of it and what would or could happen if we didn't define our question. After collecting data, we would focus on using manipulative's to show the data collected. We would then work with manipulative's to work through mean and what it shows. We would work on taking our data from our manipulative and using it to create a graph. We would look over the graph at the spread of the data to compare two groups.
3. How would you modify the lesson to make it more accessible or more challenging for your students? To make the lesson more accessible, I could assign partners to work on the activity together. I could have class discussion about, for instance, how to collect data so all student's could hear ideas of how to do it. I could assign students to use two different types of graphs when comparing data to make it more challenging. I could give them data on a third classroom and have them compare all three data sets.
4. What questions might you ask the students as you watch them work? How will they know they've asked all their classmates and asked them only once? How could they show the data they've collected using blocks? Is there another manipulative that would show their data better? How can we compare the two sets of data?
5. What might you learn about their understanding by listening to them or by observing them? I could learn if they understand how to collect data, that you get each data point from one answer and each person is only asked once. I could learn if they knew what the data they collected meant, how to compare two sets of data, and how to create a graph of the data they collected.
6. How do the concepts taught in this lesson align to the Common Core Standards?
Here's the standard for 4th grade:
| Represent and interpret data. 4. Make a line plot to display a data set of measurements in fractions of a unit (1/2, 1/4, 1/8). Solve problems involving addition and subtraction of fractions by using information presented in line plots. For example, from a line plot find and interpret the difference in length between the longest and shortest specimens in an insect collection. |
| Develop understanding of statistical variability. 1. Recognize a statistical question as one that anticipates variability in the data related to the question and accounts for it in the answers. For example, "How old am I?" is not a statistical question, but "How old are the students in my school?" is a statistical question because one anticipates variability in students’ ages. 2. Understand that a set of data collected to answer a statistical question has a distribution which can be described by its center, spread, and overall shape. 3. Recognize that a measure of center for a numerical data set summarizes all of its values with a single number, while a measure of variation describes how its values vary with a single number. |
Writing to Learn:
1. What are the first ideas about probability that students should develop? How can you help students with these ideas?
Students should develop an understanding of likely versus unlikely. They should understand that events can be likely or unlikely and that some events are more likely or less likely than others. They should understand that probability is on a continuum. You can help students with these ideas by showing them how probability is on a continuum. You could use a spinner with 4 colored spaces of different sizes. This can show students that some choices are more or less likely than others.
2. What is the difference between these two activities? Why might this difference be useful in helping students? The activity 22.3 is charting the number of times the spinner lands on either the color red or blue. The blue area covers 3/4 of the spinner where red covers 1/4 of the spinner. Activity 22.4 involves rolling two dice that have the numbers 1, 1, 2, 3, 3, 3 on the sides of each dice. Students roll both dice, add the number together, and tally their results. Activity 22.3 only has two variables where 22.4 has 3. Also, 22.4 will show results for the entire continuum of probability because it has the number 1 on the chart which is impossible to roll. 22.3 shows students how one choice maybe more or less likely than the other.
3. Explain what is meant by the statement "Chance has no memory."
When completing an experiment in chance any previous results have no baring on the future results. If you toss a coin and it lands on heads, it will have no affect on the next toss of the coin.
Dice Toss
1. Ms. Kincaid wanted the students to make predictions about their experiment on the basis of mathematical probability. Discuss preconceptions that students exhibited about tossing dice even after discussing the mathematical probability. Discuss the instructional implications of dealing with these preconceptions. Students did list options that weren't possible like 1. After thinking about it, students were able to figure out it wasn't possible and why.
- Were these students too young to discuss mathematical probability? What evidence did you observe that leads you to believe that students did or did not grasp the difference between mathematical probability and experimental probability? At what age should probability be discussed? I don't think these students were too young to discuss probability. Students were able to make predictions about the probability that each number would get rolled based on what was likely. They were able to understand that some sums were more likely than others based on how many different ways you could combine numbers to get that sum.
- The teacher asked the students, “What can you say about the data we collected as a group?” and “What can you say mathematically?” How did the phrasing of these two questions affect the students’ reasoning? One students was making a reference to a book he had read about rockets. He was looking at the shape of the graph but not focusing on the meaning of the shape. After she asked what can you say mathematically, he was able to focus on what the data was telling the class.
- Why did Ms. Kincaid require each group of students to roll the dice thirty-six times? What are the advantages and disadvantages of rolling this number of times? There were a total of 36 sums that could be made with two dice. Rolling 36 times gives you a chance to roll each sum one time. It was also an even number for each student to roll. Students were grouped in fours, so each student could roll 9 times.
- Comment on the collaboration among the students as they conducted the experiment. Give evidence that students either worked together as a group or worked as individuals. It seemed all student's were working well together as a group. They were sharing examples from previous work and helping each other keep track of where they were. One group rolled too many times and worked together to figure out what numbers they needed to erase so their data only had 36 data points.
- Why do you think Ms. Kincaid assigned roles to each group member? What effect did this practice have on the students? How does assigning roles facilitate collaboration among the group members? I think she assigned roles to each group member to get them involved in the group work and experiment. If there were no assigned roles, one or two students may take on more of a role in the group and you may have student's who aren't that involved.
- Describe the types of questions that Ms. Kincaid asked the students in the individual groups. How did this questioning further student understanding and learning? She asked them not only what their data showed but why they thought they got these results and if they were close to what they had predicted.
- Why did Ms. Kincaid let each group decide how to record the data rather than giving groups a recording sheet that was already organized? When would it be appropriate to give students an organized recording sheet? Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of allowing students to create their own recording plans. These student's had collected data before and were familiar with multiple ways to graph data. They were able to collaborate and decide which way they wanted to record their data. You would want to give a pre-made recording sheet if the student's were young or if they had never collected data before.
Geez, just typed in the wrong address and it erased my comment. I was commenting on how it seems that the common core doesn't quite speak to the statistical process. Though if you do read the script that comes with each grade level, you do get more of a sense of this.
ReplyDelete