Textbook writing to learn questions:
1. In Mathematics, your typically looking for a single answer. There is most often a correct and incorrect response. Statistics is analyzing data. It's about numbers in a context. Statistical question:
2. The shape of data refers to how the data is spread out or grouped.
3. Attribute activities are important in the development of data analysis skills because they help develop flexible reasoning about the characteristics of data.
4. K-2 students might gather data in their classroom on what is your favorite color, what is your favorite food, or how many siblings do you have? Older students might gather data on what is the favorite ice cream flavor for each grade level at their school.
5. I'm a little confused by the categories question but I would say a circle graph or pie chart can have categories also a histogram.
6. A histogram is a type of bar graph that have categories that are consecutive and are measured at equal intervals.
7. You can make a circle graph physically in a classroom by having students form a circle where they are lined up next to students with the same answer, use string to show the wedges of the circle categories. You can use percentages to make up a circle graph. You can also make a circle graph out of a bar graph by cutting out the bars taping them together and forming a circle. Circle graph tells you information about each section as compared to the whole.
8. You would use mean over median if you wanted to average say homework grades. You want to see how the student has done overall the homework assignments not just the middle assignment. You would want to use median over mean if you wanted to know how much time students spend on silent reading each month.
9. One way to interpret the mean is if the number shows what the data represents if all of the data points were level or even. The second way to interpret mean is as a central balance point. Interpreting the mean as a leveling leads to computing the mean.
I was following along with session II, taking notes, and completing the tasks. It was making very good sense and then at the end for homework I got different answers for the medians. It was frustrating to not be able to get the same answer as the session gave for something that seems so simple.
Math Activity: Median as a tool in data description
1. Describe and compare the four sets of data. Are the four grades similar? Different? When I made line plot for each grade level, I did notice some similarities. Grades kindergarten, 1st, 2nd, and 3rd are all similar in the up to seven teeth lost. After 7 teeth lost, 1st, 2nd, and 3rd grade's data spike up and then fall back to 1 or 2 students losing teeth. The Kindergarten data showed only 0-2 students losing teeth and no students lost more than 6 teeth. 3rd grade data showed students losing up to 19 teeth.
2. If just the mode for each grade were reported to you what would that tell you about the data? What wouldn’t you be able to tell? The mode for each grade were as follows: K-0, 1st-7, 2nd-8, 3rd-9. If the mode was only reported it makes it seem as if kindergarteners lost no teeth. The mode doesn't show the range of teeth lost.
3. Find the median number of teeth lost for each grade. If just the median for each grade were reported to you, how would that help you compare the grade levels? The median is a measure of center in a data set. The median for each grade level tells us what number is in the middle of the data set. We can see that kindergarten has the lowest median followed by 1st, 2nd, and then 3rd. So the median tells us that as students get older the number of teeth that they lose increases.
4. If just the median and the range were reported to you, what could you say about the data? If just the lowest value, the highest value, and the median for each grade were reported, what could you say about the data? Would these statistics give you an adequate picture of the data? What would you know about the data? What wouldn’t you know? If I had just the median and range, the data shows as the range increases the median also increases. From Kindergarten to 1st grade, the range doubled and so did the median. From 1st to 2nd grade the range only increased by one and the median increased by a half. So, there is a correlation between growth in range and increased median.
Case Studies
The case studies really showed the importance of thinking through and specifically defining the question your asking when collecting data. You don't want to leave room in your question for the respondant to interpret or guess what your asking. If you don't ask specific questions you could collect inaccurate data that doesn't answer your question at all. The case studies also showed that sometimes defining the specific question you want to ask can be difficult because you want to also ask it as simply as possible. If you think through and define your question in the beginning it can save you frustration when gathering and later analyzing data.
I scream, you scream article:
Comment on the opening statement, "That students should be able to pose questions, gather data, and represent that data in graphs seems reasonable enough – until you consider that these are the stated expectations for children just four to eight years old!"
As Cook showed, it is reasonable to expect students as young as 4-8 years old to be able to pose questions, gather data, and represent that data in graphs. Younger students will need guidance in selecting a specific, narrow question to ask for gathering data. Young students may also need help making sure they accurately gather data. Young students are able to make simple graphs to represent their data. With a little guidance, young students can particpate in statistical analysis.

It was so interesting to me how we got different numbers when we were figuring out the medians! I remember when I was in elementary school how easy the "Mean, Median, and Mode" Unit was, but looking at it from a teacher's perspective is much different! I didn't realize how difficult it was to try and explain it.
ReplyDeleteQuestion number 5 that asks you to list the graphs that put data into categories is asking which graphs are suitable for categorical data. The histogram is used with numerical data not categorical though the description in the book could have misled you to interpret "categories are consecutive equal intervals" to mean categorical data. Needed to read a bit further for the full definition.
ReplyDelete