July 29, 2013

Module 11

Circumference & Diameter:
 
Describe Ms. Scrivner's techniques for letting students explore the relationship between circumference and diameter. What other techniques could you use?  Ms.  Scrivner gave students vocabulary and had them physically show what they meant.  Students were then told to find circles to measure the circumference and diameter of in groups.  Students collected data, shared what they found with the class, then looked for the relationship between circumference and diameter.

In essence, students in this lesson were learning about the ratio of the circumference to the diameter. Compare how students in this class are learning with how you learned when you were in school.  Students in this class were learning about circumference and diameter with a hands on approach.  When I was taught, I was given the ratio or relationship between circumference and diameter.  I was then given a worksheet where either circumference or diameter was given and you had to figure out the other measurement by calculating.  I never measured anything myself. 

How did Ms. Scrivner have students develop ownership in the mathematical task in this lesson?  She told the students the activity they were doing but them let them figure out how to do it and what to measure.  She was there for guidance if students needed help but the students really drove their own learning.  They were figuring it out on their own so they developed more ownership in the lesson.

How can student's understanding be assessed with this task?  The teacher can get a good sense of the student's understanding from observing students as they work.  You could also get them to journal the important pieces they learned that day in their own words.
 
Annenberg-circle: 
Wow, I thought this would be an easy session.  I still remember a bit about circumference and diameter, but this session was tougher than I thought.  I couldn't find a tape measure around my house so I wasn't able to do the hands on part which really put me at a disadvantage I think.  It really made me think how important it will be for students to have that hands on experience.  It will make the information much more solid in their minds and practical.  For instance, the following would make more sense if I could see it by doubling a circle and measuring.  When not doing the hands on piece the values don't have much meaning to me.
Think about a circle with a radius equal to 1 (r = 1). The circumference and the area of this circle are as follows:
C = 2 • 1 • = 2
A = 12 • =
Now double the radius to 2 units (r = 2). The circumference and the area of the new circle are as follows:
C = 2 • 2 • = 4
A = 22 • = 4
The circumference of the new circle doubled, but the area is multiplied by a factor of 4 (the square of the scale factor). You can replace the 1 with any other number, or with a variable r, to see that this relationship will always hold.

Case Studies-Angles:

 
 
From the video and readings, the students seemed to understand that an angle is created when two lines intersect.  There was however, a lot of misunderstandings beyond that.  Some students thought angles only occur inside shapes.  Others thought the lines of the angle determined if it was large or small.  Some students only counted angles as the one's on the horizontal axis.  It seems like students need more experience with different sized or degrees of angles, different orientation of angles, and different placement of angles (inside shapes and outside).  I will bring this idea into my own classroom.  Just as students can start to assume that an equilateral triangle is the only triangle, they can get skewed ideas from a limited exposure with mathematical concepts.
 
Annenberg-Angles:
 

 
I think the above example is a great way to show students that angles are about measuring turn.  It really demonstrates this concept to me.  I also liked the use of straws to demonstrate the length of the rays doesn't change the angle.  This would be an easy, inexpensive way for students to examine this idea for themselves. 
I liked this question:
Examine the polygons you drew where your turns were all in one direction (either all to the right or all to the left). What is the sum of the measures of the exterior angles of each of these polygons? Is this sum the same for all polygons? Why or why not?  Although I answered this correctly, I had never thought about this in this way. 
 
How Wedge You Teach:
 
What ideas will you take from this article into your classroom? Was there anything surprising about what you read that made you change your thinking about children’s understanding of calculating an angle? What possible misconceptions might children have about angles and what misconceptions did you have about angles?
This article further demonstrates the importance of inquiry based, hands-on teaching.  Traditional teaching will teach students the vocabulary and many of the mathematical concepts but they aren't able to take that knowledge and apply it in any way.  When students develop a more fluid understanding of math they are able to stretch their understanding and apply their knowledge in various ways.  I don't think students are understanding the role the angle has in idea of a circle.  They see an angle as something to measure and name ie. acute, right, or obtuse.  Once students learn the rule that a right angle is 90 degrees an acute is less than 90 and an obtuse is more than 90, it's hard for them to describe an angle in any other way.  When students are using this vocabulary to describe angles, they still aren't truly understanding the meaning behind the words used.  I think this also shows the lack of experience students are getting with these concepts.  Their views are very narrow.
 

July 26, 2013

Module 10



Ordering Rectangles:



1. Take the seven rectangles and lay them out in front of you. Look at their perimeters. Do not do any measuring; just look. What are your first hunches? Which rectangle do you think has the smallest perimeter? The largest perimeter? Move the rectangles around until you have ordered them from the one with the smallest perimeter to the one with the largest perimeter. Record your order. After laying out the rectangles, I thought D had the smallest perimeter and G had the largest.  I ordered them from greatest to smallest as follows:  G-A-E-C-F-B-D

2. Now look at the rectangles and consider their areas. What are your first hunches? Which rectangle has the smallest area? The largest area? Again, without doing any measuring, order the rectangles from the one with the smallest area to the one with the largest area. Record your order. I thought C had the smallest area while G had the largest area.  I ordered them as follows:  G-A-E-F-B-D-C

3. Now, by comparing directly or using any available materials (color tiles are always useful), order the rectangles by perimeter. How did your estimated order compare with the actual order? What strategy did you use to compare perimeters? I used color tiles to measure the perimeter of the rectangles.  I ordered them as follows:  F-G-A-B-D-E-C.  My estimated order was pretty off the measured order.  I didn't have any in the same order after measuring them with color tiles. 
4. By comparing directly or using any available materials (again…color tiles), order the rectangles by area. How did your estimated order compare with the actual order? What strategy did you use to compare areas? I used color tiles to measure the area of the rectangles.  I found their order to be:  G-A-F-B-E-D-C.  I was closer with my guessing for area than for perimeter.  I did guess the rectangles with the greatest and least area. 
I also correctly guessed a few in the middle.

5. What ideas about perimeter, about area, or about measuring did these activities help you to see? What questions arose as you did this work? What have you figured out? What are you still wondering about? Share your responses to all the questions in 1-5 on your blog. Spend some time discussing your answers with your blog partner.
This activity helped me see that the largest area shape may not have the largest perimeter.  It can be tricky when guessing the perimeter or area of a shape because it's hard to see that by just looking at them.  There was some small space left when measuring some of the rectangles with the color tiles and I wondered how I should incorporate those spaces.  I tried to compare the left over spaces when shapes had the same number of squares for perimeter or area.  I lined the tiles up on the edge of the rectangle and then used another tile to estimate the left over space.  However, my cutting of the shape may have caused some error in this way of measuring.  I'm still not sure the best way to handle the extra spaces. 


Annenberg:
I thought this was an interesting session.  I have never measured anything by wrapping it in foil.  I thought that would be an interesting way to show students about measuring irregular shapes.  I was surprised by the following questions answer:
How does a three-arm balance scale work? Can you determine the weight of your rock with this balance?
If you have access to a three-arm balance, use it to determine the weight of your rock
I thought a three-arm balance could give you the weight of the rock not an approximation.  What type of scale can give a definite weight?  This session really made me think about the approximation of measuring.  I think I thought it was much more definite in certain cases.

Case Studies:
 


The case studies showed a progression in understanding of measurement through the grade levels.  The kindergarten students were showing they understand where to start and stop when measuring an object.  They were just learning that you need a unit of some sort to measure with.  The first grade students were working through the understanding that if the unit you measure with is larger the less times you have to use it to measure with.  The students first thought the larger number was related to the larger item used to measure with.  The third grade students were working on the same understanding as the first grade students.  They were also learning about precision and accuracy.  They were starting to understand that the precision with which they measured had a direct affect on the accuracy of their results.  They were discovery what errors could occur while measuring to cause errors in the results.  The second grade students were also learning about precision and accuracy.  They were learning that measurement is an approximation.  The fourth grade students were working with choosing the right measuring tool for the measuring task they were completing and how to properly use that tool.  Students were discussing where you start measuring at the '0' space on a ruler.  The seventh graders were working with units, regular and irregular.  They were having some trouble understanding the irregular units used would result in different results where the regular units should have resulted in the same results.

TCM Article: Length

What ideas will you take from this article into your classroom? Was there anything surprising about what you read that made you change your thinking about children’s understanding of unit? What possible misconceptions may children have about measurement? I was surprised that the students were quickly able to move from direct measurements to the more deductive reasoning.  I was surprised how much the first graders understood about measurement.  Macy was able to make a unit to compare two areas.  She also understands the bigger the unit the more space it takes up and so you use it less times to measure something.  I was also surprised by the ease in which the students used letters to express relationships between quantities.  I would definitely use this approach in my classroom.  I like that students moved from physically measuring to more conceptual ideas.  These students have a much better understanding of measurement than students who may be taught a formula and given worksheets to practice measuring with. 



July 24, 2013

Module 9


Tangram Discoveries:
Which polygon has the greatest perimeter? …the least perimeter? How do you know?  I found that 4 of my polygon's had the same perimeter and the square at the least perimeter.  Since each polygon was made by using triangles, I used the small triangle and traced it inside each polygon to fill up the space.  I then counted the sides.

Which polygon has the greatest area? …the least area? How do you know?  I think the area's are the same.  I was able to trace four small triangles inside each polygon.  However, when I used the formula of length x width and assigned values to the sides of the small triangle, it didn't work out the same.  Hmmm...so now I'm not so sure.
 
Annenberg:
The last two Annenberg sessions have been tough for me.  I had a hard time with the rotational symmetry when it came to the codes.  This question was hard for me to get:

When I see all this my eyes just want to cross over.  It feels very overwhelming to me with the letters and numbers to answer this one.  I'm more of a visual person and it would have helped me to see more examples of these movements than just the one.  After completing the entire module, I feel much more confident with this area.

Tessellating:
Tessellating is when you repeat a shape over and over again covering a plane without any gaps or spaces.  By reading this article and going step by step when creating the tessellation t-shirts, it helped me understand how tessellation is done.  It also gave me ideas for how to incorporate an activity in the classroom.  This is the tessellation I came up with:

Some examples of tessellations I found:
Toadstools.JPG
Student-birds.jpg

Coordinate Grids:
I thought these games were a lot of fun.  It was a great review for me.  I had forgotten about the four quadrant grids but it came back very fast.  I really liked the games that had a timer on them like both Billy bug games, catching the fly, and stock the shelves.  The games that were mazes were alright but not as fun for me.  I think you should use a variety of these types of games.  Just as the timed games were more interesting to me, the other types may be interesting to others.  In my classroom, I would probably have a few of these different games in a folder on the computer that students could pick which game they wanted to do during computer time.  The interactive on-line games makes practicing with coordinate grids fun for students.  The downside of the computer games is that students are really using any of the positional vocabulary.  They also may not pick up about the direction of the coordinate or the distance.  I also found these websites that have coordinate grid games as well:  http://www.mathplayground.com/locate_aliens.html (this game is finding an alien on a grid)

http://www.mathnook.com/math/skill/coordinategridgames.php ( this site has 5 different games from boats coordinates to finding flying saucers)

Mira:

Have you ever used a Mira before? Did you find any part of this problematic? How did this build on your understanding of transformations? I had never worked with a Mira before this module.  I had a lot of fun playing with it.  I didn't have any problems working with it.  It really helped me visualize some transformations.  After, using the Mira a couple of times I was better able to visualize the reflections without using it and just check my answer with it.
I enjoyed the article Investigations: Reflections and kaleidoscopes: Not always what you expect.  I liked that they started with prediction and a Mira, but then moved to a hinged mirror where students could easily investigate reflection and angles.  It was great that they ended with making a kaleidoscope.  The kaleidoscope gives students the opportunity to see reflections and math at work.

Further Discussion:
*Multicultural mathematics offer rich opportunities for studying geometry. Research the art forms of Native Americans and various ethnic groups such as Mexican or African Americans. What kinds of symmetry or geometric designs are used in their rugs, baskets, pottery, or jewelry? Discuss ways you might use your discoveries to create multicultural learning experiences.
I found a lot of examples of line symmetry, reflection symmetry, various shapes used, and tessellation in Native American vases, rugs, clothing, bags, etc.  The examples below would be a great way to incorporate the heritage and culture of Native Americans in lessons.  It could be incorporated across many subjects including math with tessellations and symmetry.  It's a great way to not only celebrate various cultures but to also show real world examples to students and prove math is truly all around them.

July 21, 2013

Module 8

Spatial Readings:

 
Did you find any of these activities challenging? If so, what about the activity made it challenging? By far the most challenging for me was the annenberg tangram segment.  I was so frustrated when trying to figure out how to make shapes with those pieces.  I also had a hard time making shapes from other shapes.  For instance, it showed a picture of a triangle and you had to figure out how to cut the shape into pieces that would make a rectangle.  It's strange how the other activities were pretty easy for me and this one was so hard. 

Why is it important that students become proficient at spatial visualization? Students with good spatial sense are better able to use geometric ideas to analyze the world around them.  They can also see geometry in art.  We use spatial visualization in our daily lives.  When we pack our car for a long trip, we can use spatial visualization to help out.


At what grade level do you believe students are ready for visual/spatial activities?  pre-k and Kindergarten students can participate in visual/spatial activities.  Research shows that spatial visualization gets better with practice so students should be exposed to it early and often.

How can we help students become more proficient in this area?

There are various activities using manipulative's or computer programs that can give students practice in this area.  Students need to have experiences where they learn how to use spatial visualization and get to practice using it.


Writing To Learn:
4.  Find one of the suggested applets for geometry or explore Wingeom and explain how it can be used.  What are the advantages of using the computer in geometry instead of the corresponding hands-on materials or drawings.
I explored Geogebra.  I thought it was really fun.  I worked with rotating a triangle across different planes and a tessellations activity.  I think a computer based geometry activity could very easily be used in the classroom.  The computer activity could be used to further explore a concept, prove a concept or definition, or reinforce a concept.  I like using the computer more than drawing because it's easier to manipulate what you're working with.  Students could move, stretch, and rotate items to gain a better understanding.  Manipulatives would give students more ability to manipulate the items than drawings but depending on the materials students may not be able to stretch the items and freely manipulate them like they could with a computer program.  Also, I haven't seen a student yet that didn't like computer time.  I can see how student's could get distracted from the assignment or activity and get off track while using these programs.  I started playing with the tessellations activity just making fun designs.  I also found this website:  http://www.neok12.com/games/pentominoes/pentominoes.htm  It has shape games, angle games, measurement games, grid games, building blocks games, and visual geometry games.  This site had so many games for kids to try that focus on geometry.  I would like to try some of these in my own classroom.

Space Shapes & Building Plans:
The three space shape activities were fun.  I got all the pictures in the right order in the trip on a train activity.  The silhouette's activity was easy with the first example but the second gave me a little trouble.  The shadow's activity was the hardest for me but after the first couple of questions I got the hang of it.  I can definitely see how student's could have fun with activities like these to work on their spatial reasoning skills.
I found the building plans activity fairly easy.  I was able to correctly create the buildings each time.  The last activity where we had to build 3 buildings, I didn't have enough blocks to build all 3 so I built the first two and figured out the correct answers from those.  I was able to visualize the buildings on each side even when I was looking straight down at them.

Annenberg Tangrams Module:
I would share my answers from this module except I was only able to get one right.  This was the most frustrating segment for me of this entire class.  I hate tangrams!  I couldn't make a square or rectangle with all the pieces.  I had a very hard time seeing how to cut one shape into others to make a new shape.  I definitely need to work more in this area. 

Pentomino:
I started with trying the website listed.  It reminded me a lot of the game Tetris.  I was able to complete both the easy and medium puzzles but couldn't get the hard one.  Although, the harder puzzle was difficult it wasn't nearly as frustrating for me as the tangrams exercises.  The pentomino puzzles were more fun for me.  I also found figuring out the puzzles with my plastic pentomino pieces was easier and faster for me than the computer version.  I later found the following website:  http://www.neok12.com/games/pentominoes/pentominoes.htm.  This website had pentomino puzzle as well but you got to pick the shape of the puzzle you wanted to complete.

Pentomino Narrow Passage:
I was a little confused by this activity when I first started and made this passage:
This was 15 squares long.
 
Then I tried again and came up with this:
 
My second attempt was 20 squares long.  I counted the open space where a square would fit if it were there to measure how long the passage was.





July 18, 2013

Module 7

Quick Images:
When I saw the image the first time I thought it looked like a crescent with a small hole in the middle.  It was interesting to hear how the student's thought about the image.  Once said it looked like a crescent like I did.  Other student's said it looked like a moon, the letter "c", half of a circle, a banana, etc.  I didn't hear any students mention the small circle inside the crescent which I thought was really interesting.  It was also interesting to hear all the different ways the student's described the image.

Case Studies:
I found it really interesting what the student's said about how they felt about expanding their knowledge.  I can definitely relate with the student's.  One student mentioned she would have to break out of the thinking she had done before and let some new ideas into her head.  I'm being taught a totally different way to teach math than the way I learned it while in school.  I definitely feel like it's not only a new way to learn math but a new way of thinking about learning math.  I feel like I need to let go of some old ideas and make way for new ones.  I was surprised that many of the third graders couldn't accurately pick out triangles unless they looked like an equilateral triangle.  I would have thought by that age they would have more knowledge about shapes than that.  These case studies really showed the importance of giving students experiences with different orientations and sizes of shapes.  As teachers, we really need to juxtapose different orientations of the same shape as well as different shapes so student's can discern the differences.

Annenberg-polygon:
How many polygons can you find in the following figure?

I only found all the polygon's with this question.  The other's I always missed a few.  It was harder for me to see all the polygon's than I thought it would be. 
I really liked working with the Venn diagram's.  It was like working backwards from how I normally work with them and made me think of other ways to use them.  I liked trying to figure out the categories not what goes in each circle. 


Math Activity:
I really liked this activity.  It was fun moving around the squares and finding shapes.  I found all the 5 square shapes except for one.  Yay!  I knew all the names of the shapes except for dodecagon. 

Nets:
How could you use a similar activity with students in the classroom? Were you able to complete the activity without too much frustration? What are some anticipated issues while doing this activity with students? You could use almost the exact same activity in the classroom.  I think it was really helpful to have the paper pieces to fold afterward to check your answers.  After the first couple nets I picked that would make a box, it was easier for me to pick others I thought would work.  Students may just want to try to fold the boxes without trying to see it first with their minds. 
What properties are common to all nets that will form a cube?
What types of nets will not work? Why not?
Without folding, is there a quick way to determine whether or not a net will fold into a cube?
These questions were a little trickier for me, I usually have a hard time seeing the pattern in things.  What I did notice was the only once that would make a box were the ones that didn't have two squares on the same side that were both touching boxes underneath them.    For instance, the first shape has two squares that both touch the squares on the horizontal axis.  This shape will not make a box.  However, the second shape has two square boxes on top but only one touches the boxes on the horizontal axis.  The second shape will make a box.

   
     
   
     




July 15, 2013

Module 6


Key idea in geometry: 


What are the key ideas of geometry that you want your students to work through during the school year? This is a tough question for me.  I guess it depends on the the grade level I'm teaching but I would want students to understand shapes and basic geometric ideas. I would want them to be able to tell how they know a shape is that particular shape.  Students should also know about angles and vertices.  I want student's to learn geometry in authentic ways.  I would want students to see the geometry around them.
 
Thinking about triangles: 
How would you structure this lesson for students in an elementary classroom? I think this lesson could easily be used in an elementary classroom.  I think students would love working with a geoboard.  I would put students in groups to complete this activity.  I would change the amount of triangles student's would have to make on their geoboard.  I would just have them make a right triangle on their geoboard.  Also, I would have each group make one triangle of any type on their board.  Groups would then share their triangle and explain how it's different from other triangle's or what makes it the type it is.

What parts did you have issues with? I didn't have too many issues with this lesson.  I always really liked geometry and still remember a lot of what I learned.  I liked using the geoboard with this lesson.  It took me a little time to get all 14 triangles on the geoboard.
Did you need to revisit some vocabulary words to remind yourself of their meanings? I remembered most of the types of triangles.
If so, which ones? I didn't remember scalene at all.  The word didn't even ring a bell.

Annenberg
I found I was much better at figuring out the answers correctly when I was actually making the triangles.  I was not very accurate when I was predicting about triangles.  I had a hard time coming up with a rule that would describe when three lengths would make a triangle.  I came up with a rule but I didn't notice it had to do with sums.  My son and I had fun with the building towers activity.  We came up with some interesting structures and proved that the one made of triangles was more secure.

July 12, 2013

Module 5

Common Core

My first two impressions are the common core standards seem pretty detailed and well explained.  The progression seems good through the grades.  However, I don't see why you you should wait, for example, until 2nd grade to teach graphing.  You can start that in kindergarten.  As the standards progress through the grades, they get more detailed and require more finesse from the student to accomplish the goals.  They require more understanding of the concepts to complete the goals as well.  The common core standards align in some places with the NCTM standards, but the NCTM standards have more requirements in them.  For instance, the common core and NCTM state students should be able to count and classify objects into categories.  The NCTM specifies attribute categories where the common core just says categories.  They both state students should be able to represent data but only the NCTM says in a concrete way.  Both standard types state students should be able to interpret data parts compared to the whole to describe what the data shows. Only NCTM discusses students expressing experiences as likely or unlikely.  Only NCTM mentions data collection by the students.  Both common core and NCTM state students in 3-5 grade should use line graphs, line plots, bar graphs.  Only the NCTM states students should be able to explain the difference in categorical and numerical data.  Both standards state students should be able to talk about the shape of data as it's center and spread.

Curriculum Resources

I chose the grade four:  how many people are in your family?

1.  When using this activity, what mathematical ideas would you want your students to work through?  I would first want my students to understand the importance of how they formulate their question to ask when collecting data.  I would want my student's to find a way to collect the data and keep track of it.  Then, I would want student's to be able to show their data in a concrete way.  Students could use blocks or other manipulative's to show their data.  I would like students to understand how to interpret or analyze their data by looking at the mean and spread.  I would finally like students to be able to express their data using a graph.

2. How would you work to bring that mathematics out?  I would break this lesson over several days so we could focus on one piece at a time.  I would first work to help student's define their question for collecting data and discuss as a class the importance of it and what would or could happen if we didn't define our question.  After collecting data, we would focus on using manipulative's to show the data collected.  We would then work with manipulative's to work through mean and what it shows.  We would work on taking our data from our manipulative and using it to create a graph.  We would look over the graph at the spread of the data to compare two groups.

3.  How would you modify the lesson to make it more accessible or more challenging for your students? To make the lesson more accessible, I could assign partners to work on the activity together.  I could have class discussion about, for instance, how to collect data so all student's could hear ideas of how to do it.  I could assign students to use two different types of graphs when comparing data to make it more challenging.  I could give them data on a third classroom and have them compare all three data sets.

4.  What questions might you ask the students as you watch them work? How will they know they've asked all their classmates and asked them only once?  How could they show the data they've collected using blocks?  Is there another manipulative that would show their data better?  How can we compare the two sets of data? 

5.  What might you learn about their understanding by listening to them or by observing them? I could learn if they understand how to collect data, that you get each data point from one answer and each person is only asked once.  I could learn if they knew what the data they collected meant, how to compare two sets of data, and how to create a graph of the data they collected.

6.  How do the concepts taught in this lesson align to the Common Core Standards? 

 

Here's the standard for 4th grade:
Represent and interpret data.
4. Make a line plot to display a data set of measurements in fractions of a unit (1/2, 1/4, 1/8). Solve problems involving addition and subtraction of fractions by using information presented in line plots. For example, from a line plot find and interpret the difference in length between the longest and shortest specimens in an insect collection.
Unless we're just doing review or I add some work on fractions in this activity it doesn't line up well with the common core standards for 4th grade.  Below is the standard for 6th grade:
Develop understanding of statistical variability.
1. Recognize a statistical question as one that anticipates variability in the data related to the question and accounts for it in the answers. For example, "How old am I?" is not a statistical question, but "How old are the students in my school?" is a statistical question because one anticipates variability in students’ ages.
2. Understand that a set of data collected to answer a statistical question has a distribution which can be described by its center, spread, and overall shape.
3. Recognize that a measure of center for a numerical data set summarizes all of its values with a single number, while a measure of variation describes how its values vary with a single number.
The activity lines up more with this standard than the other one.

Writing to Learn:

1.  What are the first ideas about probability that students should develop?  How can you help students with these ideas?
Students should develop an understanding of likely versus unlikely.  They should understand that events can be likely or unlikely and that some events are more likely or less likely than others.  They should understand that probability is on a continuum.  You can help students with these ideas by showing them how probability is on a continuum.  You could use a spinner with 4 colored spaces of different sizes.  This can show students that some choices are more or less likely than others.
2.  What is the difference between these two activities?  Why might this difference be useful in helping students?  The activity 22.3 is charting the number of times the spinner lands on either the color red or blue.  The blue area covers 3/4 of the spinner where red covers 1/4 of the spinner.  Activity 22.4 involves rolling two dice that have the numbers 1, 1, 2, 3, 3, 3 on the sides of each dice.  Students roll both dice, add the number together, and tally their results.  Activity 22.3 only has two variables where 22.4 has 3.  Also, 22.4 will show results for the entire continuum of probability because it has the number 1 on the chart which is impossible to roll.  22.3 shows students how one choice maybe more or less likely than the other.
3.  Explain what is meant by the statement "Chance has no memory."
When completing an experiment in chance any previous results have no baring on the future results.  If you toss a coin and it lands on heads, it will have no affect on the next toss of the coin.

Dice Toss
     1.  Ms. Kincaid wanted the students to make predictions about their experiment on the basis of mathematical probability. Discuss preconceptions that students exhibited about tossing dice even after discussing the mathematical probability. Discuss the instructional implications of dealing with these preconceptions.  Students did list options that weren't possible like 1.  After thinking about it, students were able to figure out it wasn't possible and why. 
  1. Were these students too young to discuss mathematical probability? What evidence did you observe that leads you to believe that students did or did not grasp the difference between mathematical probability and experimental probability? At what age should probability be discussed? I don't think these students were too young to discuss probability.  Students were able to make predictions about the probability that each number would get rolled based on what was likely.  They were able to understand that some sums were more likely than others based on how many different ways you could combine numbers to get that sum. 
  2. The teacher asked the students, “What can you say about the data we collected as a group?” and “What can you say mathematically?” How did the phrasing of these two questions affect the students’ reasoning? One students was making a reference to a book he had read about rockets.  He was looking at the shape of the graph but not focusing on the meaning of the shape.  After she asked what can you say mathematically, he was able to focus on what the data was telling the class.
  3. Why did Ms. Kincaid require each group of students to roll the dice thirty-six times? What are the advantages and disadvantages of rolling this number of times? There were a total of 36 sums that could be made with two dice.  Rolling 36 times gives you a chance to roll each sum one time.  It was also an even number for each student to roll.  Students were grouped in fours, so each student could roll 9 times. 
  4. Comment on the collaboration among the students as they conducted the experiment. Give evidence that students either worked together as a group or worked as individuals. It seemed all student's were working well together as a group.  They were sharing examples from previous work and helping each other keep track of where they were.  One group rolled too many times and worked together to figure out what numbers they needed to erase so their data only had 36 data points.
  5. Why do you think Ms. Kincaid assigned roles to each group member? What effect did this practice have on the students? How does assigning roles facilitate collaboration among the group members? I think she assigned roles to each group member to get them involved in the group work and experiment.  If there were no assigned roles, one or two students may take on more of a role in the group and you may have student's who aren't that involved. 
  6. Describe the types of questions that Ms. Kincaid asked the students in the individual groups. How did this questioning further student understanding and learning? She asked them not only what their data showed but why they thought they got these results and if they were close to what they had predicted. 
  7. Why did Ms. Kincaid let each group decide how to record the data rather than giving groups a recording sheet that was already organized? When would it be appropriate to give students an organized recording sheet? Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of allowing students to create their own recording plans. These student's had collected data before and were familiar with multiple ways to graph data.  They were able to collaborate and decide  which way they wanted to record their data.  You would want to give a pre-made recording sheet if the student's were young or if they had never collected data before. 

July 9, 2013

Module 4


Working with the mean

How did you use the cubes to figure out the problems? I stacked my cubes together in ascending order.  I then compared each stack to the stack of 8 which was the mean.  I figured out the variance from observing what stacks had more blocks or less blocks and by how many blocks they differed.  I realized that the mean of the 5 stacks was not 8 so the next two block stacks would have to compensate for that.  I then built 2 more stacks that would fit in my data set but keep the mean at 8.

How does this model help demonstrate what the mean represents? The blocks help you see that one stack is one blocker greater than eight so one stack has to be one less than eight.  It visually shows you that if you took blocks off the taller stacks and added them to the shorter stacks all block stacks would equal eight blocks.

How did you use the line plot to figure out the problem? I drew a line plot and then figured out the variance by writing if that bag was equal to 8, greater than 8, or less than 8 and by how much.  Again, it showed the mean of the 5 bags was not 8 so I knew the next 2 bags had to compensate for that.  So, I knew I needed to make up one number so I started with if I added a bag of 8 which would be even I would need to add a bag of 9 to make up for the deficit from the original 5 bags.  Then, you could change those two bags to different numbers.  If I added one bag of 7 instead of 8, I had a deficit of 2 so I would have to add a bag of 10 and so on.

How does this model help demonstrate what the mean represents? It shows that when you add an amount to one you have to take an amount from another.  It helps demonstrate that your working with equal amounts and how your data varies from equal. 

What does an average tell us about the whole data set? The average of a data set tells us what each share of that data would be if it was distributed evenly among all the points.

Generating mean article:

I was in elementary school so long ago things were definitely different.  The teacher taught us the algorithm for figuring out mean and we practiced it until we knew how to do it on our own.  It was a long time later before I really understood that the average was about equal shares.  Whenever I talked about the average, I knew that just meant add all the data points up and divide by the number of data points.  I'm excited to learn a better way to teach mean. 

How much taller?

In the video and case studies, it sounded like the students had about as much understanding of what the mean is as I did when I was in elementary school.  It was clear the students had been taught how to find the mean but not what it told them about the data.  Many of the kids explained how they came up with the number they were calling the mean when explaining what it meant.  It seemed like some students were getting close to figuring out the mean but just weren't quite there.  I think if they had been using some manipulative's and could see what they were doing when they were taking a couple inches of one student and adding to another they might have been able to more clearly see what was happening.  I liked being able to read not only what the teacher was saying to the students but her thoughts about it afterward.

Variation about the mean

I found figuring out the degree of fairness to be interesting.  I've never done that before.  The deviations from the mean seemed fairly easy to understand and complete.  I didn't have trouble finding the MAD or the variance.  I had a little more trouble when it came to standard deviation.  It's been a long time since I've used standard deviations and I learned how to compute it differently.  I had also forgotten how to do square roots. 

Newspaper article

Article:  Minor League Notes - Hatcher leading Triple-A in saves

In the article listed, the following sentence appears:  In 118 appearances in the minors, Hatcher, 28, has a 1.86 earned-run average and 41 saves. His MLB ERA is 5.40.
This earned run average means that Hatcher gave up, on average, 1.86 earned runs per nine innings in his last 118 times pitching.  So, for each game Hatcher pitched in he gave up 1.86 runs per inning.  Earned run averages (ERA) can be used to compare the effectiveness of pitchers against each other.


Salary:

"All teachers are paid on a scale that takes into account their years of experience. Teachers who have a master's degree also get a 10 percent supplement. For example, a teacher with five years of experience and a bachelor's degree would make $31,220 a year. A five-year teacher with a master's degree would make $34,340.  "We're implementing a pay for excellence system that will include $10.2 million to fund annual pay raises for teachers whose effectiveness is measured based on performance evaluations and data," she said."

The salary article was about North Carolina taking away the incentive of a higher salary for a teacher getting an advanced degree.  This article stated that the average salary for a teacher after 5 years was $31,220 a year.  This article gave the average pay for teachers it doesn't state which local area got paid more or less.  It didn't say if this average figure was just a base salary or if any bonuses or incentives were included.

 

July 5, 2013

Module 3


Lost teeth video:









Why might the teacher ask students to think about differences in the range at each grade level? The teacher wanted the students to predict how the data might be different for each grade level.  She wanted them to think about what would make the data change from grade level to grade level. 

What insight do you get into children's thinking as they talked about why the ranges would be different? As the children start their discussion, you can hear them discussing their own personal experiences with losing teeth and how old they were.  They begin to understand that the older the student the longer they'be had to lose teeth so the range for upper grades should be higher.

Did the children notice what you consider to be important features of the data? Are there features that they didn't notice?  The students noticed how the data clumped together in different areas for different grades.  The students also noticed outliers just as 6 teeth lost for kindergarten.  They noticed how many teeth each grade lost the most and the least. 

Describing Distributions

I felt like there was a lot of material covered in this session.  I like learning about creating stem and leaf plots (which I had never done before) and how to convert information from one graph to another.  I do feel a little bombarded by all this information and I hope I can keep it all straight.  I'm still not sure if I had a bunch of data staring at me if I would know which graph to use.

Example of line graphs:
The first example of a line graph shows the increase in temperatures in New York over 6 days.  The second ling graph shows the decrease in value of a girl's car over a 6 year period.  Line graphs were used because they wanted to show the relationship between the data points.  The line graph shows if the one data point is higher or lower than the previous one. 

July 2, 2013

Module 2



Textbook writing to learn questions:

1.  In Mathematics, your typically looking for a single answer.  There is most often a correct and incorrect response.  Statistics is analyzing data.  It's about numbers in a context.  Statistical question: 
2.  The shape of data refers to how the data is spread out or grouped. 
3.  Attribute activities are important in the development of data analysis skills because they help develop flexible reasoning about the characteristics of data.
4.  K-2 students might gather data in their classroom on what is your favorite color, what is your favorite food, or how many siblings do you have?  Older students might gather data on what is the favorite ice cream flavor for each grade level at their school. 
5.  I'm a little confused by the categories question but I would say a circle graph or pie chart can have categories also a histogram.
6.  A histogram is a type of bar graph that have categories that are consecutive and are measured at equal intervals.
7.  You can make a circle graph physically in a classroom by having students form a circle where they are lined up next to students with the same answer, use string to show the wedges of the circle categories.  You can use percentages to make up a circle graph.  You can also make a circle graph out of a bar graph by cutting out the bars taping them together and forming a circle.  Circle graph tells you information about each section as compared to the whole. 
8.  You would use mean over median if you wanted to average say homework grades.  You want to see how the student has done overall the homework assignments not just the middle assignment.  You would want to use median over mean if you wanted to know how much time students spend on silent reading each month.
9.  One way to interpret the mean is if the number shows what the data represents if all of the data points were level or even.  The second way to interpret mean is as a central balance point.  Interpreting the mean as a leveling leads to computing the mean.




 
Data Organization and Representation Blog from Annenberg

I was following along with session II, taking notes, and completing the tasks.  It was making very good sense and then at the end for homework I got different answers for the medians.  It was frustrating to not be able to get the same answer as the session gave for something that seems so simple.

Math Activity:  Median as a tool in data description

1.  Describe and compare the four sets of data. Are the four grades similar? Different?  When I made line plot for each grade level, I did notice some similarities.  Grades kindergarten, 1st, 2nd, and 3rd are all similar in the up to seven teeth lost.  After 7 teeth lost, 1st, 2nd, and 3rd grade's data spike up and then fall back to 1 or 2 students losing teeth.  The Kindergarten data showed only 0-2 students losing teeth and no students lost more than 6 teeth.  3rd grade data showed students losing up to 19 teeth. 

2.  If just the mode for each grade were reported to you what would that tell you about the data? What wouldn’t you be able to tell?  The mode for each grade were as follows:  K-0, 1st-7, 2nd-8, 3rd-9.  If the mode was only reported it makes it seem as if kindergarteners lost no teeth.  The mode doesn't show the range of teeth lost. 

3.  Find the median number of teeth lost for each grade. If just the median for each grade were reported to you, how would that help you compare the grade levels?  The median is a measure of center in a data set.  The median for each grade level tells us what number is in the middle of the data set.  We can see that kindergarten has the lowest median followed by 1st, 2nd, and then 3rd.  So the median tells us that as students get older the number of teeth that they lose increases.

4.  If just the median and the range were reported to you, what could you say about the data? If just the lowest value, the highest value, and the median for each grade were reported, what could you say about the data? Would these statistics give you an adequate picture of the data? What would you know about the data? What wouldn’t you know?  If I had just the median and range, the data shows as the range increases the median also increases.  From Kindergarten to 1st grade, the range doubled and so did the median.  From 1st to 2nd grade the range only increased by one and the median increased by a half.  So, there is a correlation between growth in range and increased median.

Case Studies

The case studies really showed the importance of thinking through and specifically defining the question your asking when collecting data.  You don't want to leave room in your question for the respondant to interpret or guess what your asking.  If you don't ask specific questions you could collect inaccurate data that doesn't answer your question at all.  The case studies also showed that sometimes defining the specific question you want to ask can be difficult because you want to also ask it as simply as possible.  If you think through and define your question in the beginning it can save you frustration when gathering and later analyzing data.

I scream, you scream article:
Comment on the opening statement, "That students should be able to pose questions, gather data, and represent that data in graphs seems reasonable enough – until you consider that these are the stated expectations for children just four to eight years old!"

As Cook showed, it is reasonable to expect students as young as 4-8 years old to be able to pose questions, gather data, and represent that data in graphs.  Younger students will need guidance in selecting a specific, narrow question to ask for gathering data.  Young students may also need help making sure they accurately gather data.  Young students are able to make simple graphs to represent their data.  With a little guidance, young students can particpate in statistical analysis.

June 28, 2013

Module 1

 
 

There's such variety in the students enrolled in this class, I have no idea what famous names will be listed for having a conversation with.  I think the most interesting thing will by the reason's why they chose the person they did to have a conversation with.  Most of the time, choices like these are made because of some inspiring reason.  Some are emotionally inspiring, some mentally inspiring, some success inspiring, and I'm sure in this group some will be educationally inspiring.  I will probably learn more about the people named even if I already knew about them.  I love finding out what inspires other people. 
 
Putting the names in groups was harder than I thougth it would be.  I tried to use as few groups as possible but it was hard to get all the names to fit in.  I came up with the following groups:
 
Religious
Jesus Christ
Jesus Christ
Jesus
Pope Francis
 
Entertainers (actors, authors, singers)
Marilyn Monroe
Maya Angelou
Maya Angelou
Dr.  Seuss
Ernest Hemmingway
Margaret Mitchell
Tina Fey
Judy Bloom
Hank Williams Sr.
Fred Rogers
 
World Leaders
George Washington
Thomas Jefferson
Princess Diana
Princess Diana
Peyton Manning
Warren Buffett
Michelle Obama
Martin Luther King Jr
Ghandi
 
Inventors-Creators
Lev Vygotsky
Haregewoin Teferra
Helen Keller
John Melia
The Wright Brothers
Ron Clark
 
 
Our class data shows many people find those in the entertainment field inspiring while religious inspiration shows the smallest group.  There were the same amount of names listed in the entertainment group as in the leaders group.  I could seperate the leaders category further while the entertainment group fits together more easily.  There wasn't an overly dominating group that most names were listed in.  The groups that I chose show 4 names, 6 names, 9 names, and 10 names.  Really, depending on how I group the names it can totally change the meaning of the results.  I could move a couple names around and the data would show our class finds the most inspiration in a different group. 
 
I would also like to how each person found out about the famous person they listed.  Did they read about them, hear an interview, watch them on tv, hear about them from someone else, or someother way?  I would also want to know they came up with the name they chose.  Was it the first name that popped in their head, have they thought about this before, or some other reason? 
 
There was definitely some names that wouldn't initially fit in a category I had made.  When this happened, I reconfigured the groups.  I didn't want to leave any data out. 

Statistics in Elementary Grades
I don't remember using many physical things in the classroom to work with statistics when I was in elementary school.  I remember looking at bar graphs but I don't remember making them with data we collected in the classroom. 

How Many Pockets
Students are sitting on the floor in a circle during this lesson.  I notice this works well because they are able to talk with each other and show each other how many pockets they have.  All students are also able to clearly see the board.  The teacher uses counting their pockets to show students a line plot.  Counting their own pockets is something easy for the students to do so they aren't caught up in the data collection and can focus on the line plot.  The teacher uses good wait time when asking questions giving students time to think through the question and answer.  She was patient in waiting for every student to have time to count their pockets.  She also made sure students knew what they were defining as a pocket to count.  I was surprised by the students responses to the teacher's questions.  Since this was a second grade classroom, I was expecting better communication and insight with their answers.  The student's did start to understand how to put data on a line plot and how to read a line plot.  They were working through the 4 steps of statistical analysis.  They first asked a question-how many pockets do you have.  Then they collected data-counting the pockets of each student.  They analyzed the data-they put their data on a line plot.  Then they began interpreting the results together.  They also briefly talked about range which showed the students how to get more information from a line plot.  I was surprised how quickly you could fit in a quick lesson like this and the students could really learn new math concepts. 

Statistics as a problem solving model
When I hear the word statistics I think simply of data.  I think of perenctages and some type of analyzation of data. 
A statistical question:  How many pets do my classmates have?  First, I would ask each student if they had pets and how many they had if they answered yes.  Then, I would analyze the data collected using a bar graph.  Finally, I would interpret the results the bar graph showed.
A statistical question and population:  How many students in my school ride a bike?  You could use a representative sample of the population of the elementary school.  You could ask a few students from several different classes at each grade level to get a representative sample.  You would need to include car riders, walkers, and bus riders. 
If you only got data from grades 4th and 5th this would not be a representative population for your question. 

Further questions
The statistical process involves asking a question, collecting data, analyzing the data collected, and interpreting the results.